New York, NY – The U.S. workers’ compensation insurance market reported strong underwriting performance for the third consecutive year in 2017, with an industry statutory combined ratio of approximately 92%, according to Fitch Ratings. However, a steady decline in premium rates from increased competition will ultimately lead to weaker underwriting results.
Fitch believes that while the industry may still generate underwriting profits this year, workers’ compensation results will move toward break-even in 2019, with low visibility of longer term projected results due to historical performance volatility.
Positive performance drivers include underwriting exposure growth, continued falling claims frequency rates and conservative reserve levels. We note past underwriting and pricing actions and relatively stable loss trends have positively influenced recent market performance. Recognition of greater reserve redundancies in 2017 also partly drove results, which totaled ~12% of market earned premiums. We believe favorable loss reserve redundancies will materialize for the next few years but to a lessening degree than in 2017.
Factors that can negatively affect future industry performance include premium rate pressure, increasing medical loss severity and erosion of past reform benefits in key states. We note market direct written premium volume in 2017 declined by 30 bps from the prior year to $56 billion, representing the first year of lower market premiums since 2010. Net written premiums fell by 1.3% during the same time, mainly due to larger reinsurance cessions. Premium revenue weakness, along with greater technology-related spending, has led to higher expense ratios, which have risen two points since 2014 for the industry.
Workers’ compensation premium growth will continue to lag other commercial lines segments due largely to divergent pricing trends. According to the Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers’ quarterly Commercial Property/Casualty Market Index Survey, renewal rates in the workers’ compensation segment declined in each of the past 13 consecutive quarters. The 1Q18 survey showed a 2% rate decline, with more than half of survey participants reporting a rate decline in their last renewal. Improved growth in underwriting exposures as employee payrolls expand from higher wages and employment levels in an improving economy is anticipated to somewhat offset near-term revenue pressure.
Shifts in loss cost trends, particularly claims severity, represent a source for future workers’ compensation performance deterioration that bears further monitoring. Both indemnity and medical claims cost severity were relatively stable compared with historical norms for nearly a decade but ticked up recently. The National Council on Compensation Insurance’s latest State of the Line presentation notes an increase in workers’ compensation indemnity and medical cost claims severity of 4% each in 2017.
Fitch maintains a negative sector outlook for U.S. commercial lines insurers largely due to increased competition and the effect on near-term profit expectations. Most commercial insurers in Fitch’s rated universe have Stable Rating Outlooks. Favorable experience in workers’ compensation has partially offset weaker recent results in other key segments. Underwriting profits in commercial lines overall would influence a return to a stable sector outlook.
Fitch’s U.S. Workers Compensation Market Update report tracks market share and underwriting performance of the largest market participants over the past five years. The Travelers Companies, Inc. and Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. led the workers’ compensation market in written premiums for the past four consecutive years. Companies with tremendous growth in recent years include Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (BRK) American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) and Amtrust Financial Services, Inc. Companies that greatly reduced segment premiums over time to address performance issues include American International Group, Inc. (AIG) and Liberty Mutual Insurance Group.
Click here for the full report: U.S. Workers’ Compensation Market Update (Standout Performer in Commercial Lines)